HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
'The Children's Rose' Reviews & Comments
Discussion id : 110-264
most recent 27 APR HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 27 APR by jeffbee
this rose is VERY vigorous, grows very fast.
it is very fragrant with citrus scent with some tone of tropical fruits like mango.
the quality of the pale pink petals are very good, forming an elegant high centered shape.
it can do well as cut flower, it has long straight stems and stays like 5-7 days.
due to my experience, it needs more water to grow well.
REPLY
Discussion id : 95-856
most recent 27 OCT SHOW ALL
 
Initial post 12 NOV 16 by Badger Rose
Such a beautiful rose. It has an innocent pale pink on the upper surface and a slightly darker almost brush-stroke effect on the reverse of the petals that makes for a subtle contrast. The buds are huge, petal-packed (which hide their stamens), held proud and straight, and last for a long time on the bush or in a vase. I would like some more basal stems at the bottom so hopefully I can coax some more out next spring. The rose is over 6' this year (its 3rd year), having gotten there all the way from ground zero. I live in zone 5a so between the cold and the voles not much is left of my roses come spring. I'm impressed by its strong branching where other roses' secondary branches are weaker and floppy. This rose blackspots for me but pretty much all of my roses do even though I selected them for disease resistance. This is something I need to work on. The fragrance is great; more of a classic scent to me. Love it.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 21 posted 12 NOV 16 by HMF Admin
So nice of you to take the time to share your experience, thank you.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 21 posted 20 NOV 16 by G. Byron
Nice to hear this beautiful rose does as well in zone 5a as in my zone 10a. Mine, second year, is nearly 6', very strong shooting, and still flowering on 20 November. Strong, sweet fragrance that holds up in the summer heat. A little mildew, but otherwise no disease. While the general description of the rose says nearly thornless, mine has quite large and nasty thorns. Nevertheless one of my three favourite pink roses when it comes to scent and flower form.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 21 posted 24 DEC 16 by Badger Rose
Now that it is winter I see that the plant is thornier towards the base but the farther up you go the fewer thorns there are.
REPLY
Reply #4 of 21 posted 10 JUN 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
A zone 5a person told me to winter-protect Frederic Mistral, but I forgot to winter-protect it one winter, and lost it after 3 years. When I dug Fred up, its roots were big and woody like trees' roots, but they run on the surface, and don't go deep past 1 foot like Austin roses. Frederic Mistral needs at least 6 inch. of wood-chips or leaves to keep moist, otherwise roots dry out and die if there's no snow in the winter.
REPLY
Reply #5 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by Badger Rose
You seem to be correct. I lost Fred this spring, having failed to cover him. The snow melted super early this year and went through a brutal freeze/thaw cycle. NOOOO! FRED!!! I will dig up the roots to see if mine grew the same way and let you know.
REPLY
Reply #6 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by Lavenderlace
He seems to like heat here so far, very vigorous. I have them in sandy soil but giving them a lot of water. Does he prefer clay? Thanks!
REPLY
Reply #7 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
Clay was what killed my Frederic Mistral. When Fred was in dense clay, he was really stingy. I had to move him to a dry spot, and fixed my clay with 1 bag of coarse sand, then he bloomed much better. But it's still heavy clay at bottom, so Fred's roots could not go deep, and got zapped by a dry winter.
REPLY
Reply #8 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by Lavenderlace
Sorry about your Fred, but that sounds like good news for my soil, thanks!
REPLY
Reply #9 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by G. Byron
I also have quite sandy soil and I now have two Freds, both doing well.
REPLY
Reply #11 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by Lavenderlace
Thank you!
REPLY
Reply #10 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
Lavenderlace: I'm looking out my window. Golden Celebration has light-green foliage like Fred. If you are a fragrance-lover, Golden Celebration is a must. I wish I bought 2. G.C. does well for a person in sandy soil & hot climate, so I suspect the light-green foliage prefer loamy soil. Golden Celebration has more petals than Jude but it's more vigorous than Jude. Roses Unlimited have it on sale for $12 now. https://rosesunlimitedsc.com/
REPLY
Reply #12 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by Lavenderlace
I am definitely a fragrance lover! Thanks for the tip. Yellow doesn't look great here with our sun-burned landscape but yesterday I had huge bouquets of Sharifa Asma, Everlyn, Jude the Obscure, with the yellow Lemon Spice having the best fragrance to everybody's nose here, Jude second.

I wonder if there's something to the yellow or if it's just a coincidence? By far surpassing universally acknowledged fragrance favorites like Double Delight, Madame IP, Mr, Lincoln, Memorial Day, SDLM, etc., in my climate.
REPLY
Reply #13 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
I think yellow has the "Pernetiana" trait that likes it hot & dry & alkaline, such as Sutter's Gold. I'm VERY PICKY about yellow that fades, that's why I like Golden Celebration so much, since it doesn't fade like Julia child (which has a weird cough-syrup scent). Golden Celebration smells better than cupcakes from the oven, like a cross between a bakery and a florist shop, so addictive !! I will risk looking like an idiot asking Roses Unlimited to change my order for a 2nd Golden Celebration due to addiction, but I'll do anyway.
REPLY
Reply #14 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by Lavenderlace
LOL, I definitely understand that!
REPLY
Reply #16 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
One thing that I miss the most about Frederic Mistral (a French Romantica) is how well it handled hot sun above 90 F. It was next to a cement foundation, with radiated heat, and leaves never scorch.

I have a hard-time with light-green foliage, it spells "stingy" for dense & heavy clay. Charles Darwin has light-green foliage, and really stingy as own-root in my heavy clay. when I dug to give it away, its root is 1/4 the size of dark-green foliage Scepter'd Isle.
REPLY
Reply #17 of 21 posted 14 JUN 17 by Lavenderlace
James Galway looks very beautiful though Straw!

On comparing roses, I have a feeling what works for me will be the opposite of what works for you! Charles de Gaulle and Love Potion with very dark leaves are being watered twice a day now because my fast draining soil won't stay wet enough for them.
REPLY
Reply #15 of 21 posted 13 JUN 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
G. Byron: Thank you for a fantastic review of Fredreric Mistral .. I agree, and really appreciate your info. of Fred does well in sandy soil & hot summer. How's your garden in Scotland compared to Menorca, Spain. And how's the climate / soil difference on the 2 locations? My last house was acidic clay (only 1/2 hour away), and my current house is alkaline clay .. roses are much healthier in alkaline clay.

I click on G. Byron to find roses listed in your garden, to see which ones prefer sandy soil & hot weather. But it's best to ask you directly, since some roses may be grafted, rather than own-roots. With own-roots, the right type of soil is important.
REPLY
Reply #18 of 21 posted 14 JUN 17 by G. Byron
How I envy you all in North America in being able to get own root roses so easily. Nearly every rose I buy here, whether I get it from the UK or France (my two main sources) or other European countries, seems to be grafted.
I must start to make my list of the roses I grow. I've been here in Menorca only about 5 years, so have been doing a lot of experimenting, and a lot of roses - once I used to love in the damp cool climate of Scotland - don't work here, especially the old roses like Bourbons. So there have been many roses tossed out, I'm afraid, over those 5 years. It's been a steep learning curve.

A lot of the French roses do work exceptionally well here, like Fred and Andre le Notre, Parfum de Liberte. They make very large bushes though and can't be kept low.

The American rose Pope Jean Paul II is another winner here, with almost continual bloom. And Don Juan is (had him 2 years) doing very well. I find it so hard to find a red rose that doesn't fade to a rather awful pink here.

But will start making my list asap.
REPLY
Reply #19 of 21 posted 14 JUN 17 by Lavenderlace
That's so helpful, G. Byron. Thanks for that information!
REPLY
Reply #20 of 21 posted 14 JUN 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
Yes, French roses like Meilland or Romantica (Frederic Mistral, Bolero, Sweet Promise 2007, Liv Tyler, Betty White, Dee-lish) are fantastic as own-roots for my hot summer up to 100 F .. they are vigorous for my rock hard clay. My soil and tap water are alkaline, and the French roses have thick roots to secrete acid to push through my heavy clay. French roses can take full-sun with thick leaves & thick petals .. cut-blooms last long in the vase. One summer the sun was so intense that I had to wear a large hat to work the garden .. otherwise my head hurt from the heat !! That summer every Austin blooms were burnt to crisp or blow fast with the hot wind, but French blooms withstand the strong wind and the intense heat. French roses also smell fantastic regardless of hot or cold, but Austin roses lose their scent in hot & dry, except for Austins that bloom easily with alkaline tap water: Evelyn, Mary Magdalene, Radio Times, Pat Austin and Golden Celebration .. but these are best in partial shade.
REPLY
Reply #21 of 21 posted 27 OCT by Chirotteri
G. Byron you can get own roots roses from Italy!

Nino Sanremo: a large catalogue!
Rosso Tiziano: old roses. Try Tea roses, stand heat very well!
Mondorose: good catalogue, only some are grown on own roots though.

Then you might consider "Rose Barni", italian roses for warm climates. I suggest 'Le Toscane' HT with 'antique' blooms.

...and if you like the big and bautiful Americans, "Le Rose di Nicola Cavina" sells a good selection (grafted).
REPLY
Discussion id : 48-861
most recent 28 APR 17 SHOW ALL
 
Initial post 19 OCT 10 by Penelope
I have room for one more pink rose bush and I'm having trouble deciding between Frederic Mistral and Memorial Day. I live in Texas. If anyone can offer any advice I'd appreciate it. :-)
REPLY
Reply #1 of 6 posted 5 FEB 11 by A-L in New Orleans
I'd love to know the answer to this. I'm in New Orleans, and don't spray. Might this one work for me?
REPLY
Reply #2 of 6 posted 21 JAN 16 by N. Pierce's Garden
I grow both in Dallas. Both are a beautiful pink, have loads of fragrance, grow to be big bushes. Frederic Mistral's blooms have better form for me and it is one of the last to start blooming in the spring here. If I had to pick one over the other, I would grow Frederic Mistral; if for no other reason than it is more difficult to locate and I like to keep more difficult-to-find varieties in my garden.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 6 posted 15 SEP 16 by Lavenderlace
Which one did you decide on? I planted a lot of Memorial Days this year but wanted to go with Frederic also when available. Scent is a top trait for me so curious about which one does best in the heat!
REPLY
Reply #4 of 6 posted 28 APR 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
Frederic Mistral did well in the heat for me. It was Prickles (Bailey) in CA who reported in forum that he had 2 Memorial Day, one in full-sun, one in partial shade. The one in partial shade had better color & more petals & better scent. Lavenderlace: I would love to learn from your assessment with many Memorial Day planted in different locations as to winter-survival & vigor. Thanks. Memorial Day is iffy for my zone 5a winter, and I would like to learn what help with its vigor & winter-survival.
REPLY
Reply #5 of 6 posted 28 APR 17 by Lavenderlace
I found MD to be a little hit or miss for me in my climate. I have them all over the place and all planted within a month or so of each other.

Before planting, they did not take the summer heat with delayed UPS trucks and many arrived DOA while plants of a different variety were fine.

After winter, none of them died completely, but I have some that are now only inches tall (after dying down to the ground) in the same line where some are three feet tall and stayed green the entire winter. But the ones that came out the worse are the ones that went into winter looking the worse, though everything else was the same.

The ones in clay really struggled to get started last year but this year I don't see a difference between the clay and the sandy soil ones. But the main thing that I learned was that MD (in my particular circumstances) does not like too much water and I had some planted by very thirsty Austins!

So if I would have known this starting out, perhaps the clay ones would have done better to begin with? If there's a heavy rain, MD looks unhappy and will get a bit of BS.

Mine are all planted in full sun or else getting a lot of sun, none that I would consider shaded. I have one in a pot that has just been sitting there for six months, not a lot of growth, so being brought in for the cold and having the water controlled seems to still result in a slow starting plant.

That being said, I have at least a dozen that have huge blooms and stayed green all winter. If these were the only ones that I owned, I would say that they are fabulous! But then I have a lot that are incredibly behind so maybe they are just slow starters?

For winter protection, they had a manure and shavings mix banked around them.
REPLY
Reply #6 of 6 posted 28 APR 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
Thank you !! it's good to know that Memorial Day require less water than Austin roses. Definitely will grab that one if I see in local store.
REPLY
Discussion id : 63-935
most recent 29 MAY 16 SHOW ALL
 
Initial post 30 APR 12 by SteveinAus
If someone came to me and said they wanted advice on which rose to buy if they only had room for one, this would possibly be the one I would recommend (as long as they had plenty of room and they like the colour).
Just don't try to grow it in a pot though, as it won't grow anywhere near as well as it will in the ground, unless the pot is seriously huge and you water it about twice a day in the warmer weather. These produce lots of big blooms and they seem to need a lot of water.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 2 posted 17 AUG 15 by jmys
I took your advice and bought Frederic in November. OMG is this a beautiful rose. Thank you.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 2 posted 29 MAY 16 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
Agree that Frederic Mistral needs lots of water. After a few years, mine as own-root died through a dry winter. When I dug it up, its own-root was huge, but got dried out.
REPLY
© 2018 HelpMeFind.com