HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsGardensBuy From 
'Golden Zest ™' rose Reviews & Comments
Discussion id : 110-102
most recent 21 APR HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 21 APR by jeffbee
the flower is very like golden celebration, but stays longer. can flower in small clusters.
very double with lots of petals. warm yellow with a little bit of gold tone, the color is very pleasant to the eye, and can match other colored roses easily.
the scent is strong and is half lemon and half cinnamon or some other spices.(which I do not like, I prefer the scent of golden celebration)
vigor is good.
REPLY
Discussion id : 54-192
most recent 15 MAY 11 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 15 MAY 11 by AnneU
This rose is certainly 'Golden Zest', syn 100 Idées Jardins.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 1 posted 15 MAY 11 by jedmar
Indeed, thank you!
REPLY
Discussion id : 50-141
most recent 29 NOV 10 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 29 NOV 10 by steve fritz
This rose smells like black pepper in my garden. An attractive flower but the plant is lanky and highly susceptible to black spot
REPLY
Reply #1 of 1 posted 29 NOV 10 by HMF Admin
Thanks for taking the time to share your experience.
REPLY
Discussion id : 45-250
most recent 30 MAY 10 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 29 MAY 10 by Jimmy
This rose is also known as 'Sweet Caitlin' or 'Sweet Kathleen' in Australia.
Avaliable in Swane's nurseries Australia.

I find it frustrating when the rose names keep changing. When I first typed in Sweet Caitlin on HMF, there were no matching results. I was excited because I thought this must be a new rose only made available in Australia. Two years later, I found out that 'Sweet Caitlin' goes by another name called, 'Golden Zest' in US. Pretty disappointed.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 7 posted 29 MAY 10 by Patricia Routley
Thanks Jimmy.
Can you quote a reference that we can link 'Sweet Caitlin' with 'Jacbelgo'? The picture of 'Sweet Caitlin' on page 1 of the 2006 Australian Rose Annual certainly seems to be the same rose.

Swanes come up with some wonderful new names that take a lot of tracking down.
They have another rose called 'Sweet Cailin' - syn 'Sweet Colleen' and I havent yet found out what that one may be.

And still another one, 'Mary MacKillop' that seems to have been bred in America, but Modern Roses has it as coming from Swanes in Australia. How did they do that?

You're disappointed. I get just plain mad.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 7 posted 29 MAY 10 by Jimmy
I googled Sweet Caitlin and Jacbelgo together and Swanes rose guide 2008 (catalogue) appeared in the search. The rose catalogue states:

"Sweet CAITLIN (JACbelho) Height:140cm Colour:Lemon yellow. FRAGRANCE: Sweet with citrus tang."

I assume the bracket means the rose original /synonymous name. The catalogue also list "Sweet Cailin" - syn "Sweet Collen" as JAC untor. Again, if you google that,
JAC untor is "Peach Petticoat".

Honestly, I prefer the name, Sweet Caitlin over golden zest or Jacbelho. "Golden Zest" sounds a bit too "plain" and ordinary. I wouldn't have bought it if was named, "Golden Zest".

The name, "Sweet Caitlin", however, sounds a lot interesting. In fact, Swanes gave this rose a very nice description:

"This is a truly beautiful rose, charming and fresh like an Irish colleen. It has a sweet perfume with strong citrus characteristics. Fully cupped yellow blooms are set off in glorious splendour against the intense dark green foliage. Caitlin (Kathleen) was adopted by Irish writers as a pseudonym for Ireland. Following the enactment of repressive laws towards the close of the 17th century poets and writers were unable to refer to Ireland by name, so they introduced other names including that of Caitlin (Kathleen)"

I suppose it's all to do with MARKETING, MARKETING....
REPLY
Reply #3 of 7 posted 30 MAY 10 by Unregistered Guest
It would be great if consent is gained from the appropriate persons/authority, in order to create a HMF listing for the different rose, 'Sweet Cailin (Colleen)' (aka JACuntor). There is currently no listing for this rose on HMF.
REPLY
Reply #4 of 7 posted 30 MAY 10 by HMF Admin
Adding new plants or synonyms is not an exact science. We are always anxious about add a duplicate just because a nursery opts to introduce a plant under a different name.

In this case, there seems confusion enough already. Our interpretation is Sweet Caitlin' aka 'Jacbelgo' was offered in the Swane's catalog in 2007 & 2008 but no longer seems available. We not sure where the Sweet Caitlin' and JACuntor connection comes in.
REPLY
Reply #5 of 7 posted 30 MAY 10 by Unregistered Guest
The connection comes from the discussion further up where Patricia and then Jimmy noted that Swane's nurseries also offer a very similarly named rose to 'Sweet Caitlin' called 'Sweet Cailin'..(both are different rose cultivars)... yes you read it correctly, just one letter difference in the name.

As I write here, I am also looking at a current Swane's rose catalogue. It is clear from the pictures as well as the written commentary in this catalogue, that 'Sweet Caitlin (Kathleen)' (aka JACbelgo) and 'Sweet Cailin (Colleen)' (aka JACuntor) are being offered for sale as two very different looking roses with a similar common theme to these two names....On the page where these two distinct roses are featured, the catalogue explains that "Caitlin (Kathleen)" and "Cailin (Colleen)" are female names that have historically come to be embraced in Irish popular culture.
REPLY
Reply #6 of 7 posted 30 MAY 10 by HMF Admin
Yes, we missed the slight difference in the name - we've added it. Thank you for bringing it to our attention.
REPLY
Reply #7 of 7 posted 30 MAY 10 by Unregistered Guest
Ok.
REPLY
© 2019 HelpMeFind.com