HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
'Wekdidusinra' rose Reviews & Comments
Discussion id : 53-512
most recent 28 DEC SHOW ALL
Initial post 15 APR 11 by k~T~h o'Silicon Valley
APL 2011 ~ White Licorice is on sale for $35.00 at SummerWinds Nursery(formally Woolworth Garden Centers) in Silicon Valley,CA stores.
Reply #1 of 19 posted 13 MAR 16 by Blue Zinnia
Grossly overpriced. Edmunds has it for around $18 and Witherspoon for around $23, and even with shipping it works out cheaper. Edmunds' plants are good, but Witherspoon's are enough better to warrant the additional $5; in fact, they're the best I've ever seen, from a mail-order place or any other seller.
Reply #2 of 19 posted 2 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
I saw many bare-root-body-bag & grafted-on Dr.Huey White Licorice on sale at Menards this spring for less than $5.
Reply #3 of 19 posted 3 MAY 17 by Blue Zinnia
That's great, and I'll go look. We're having trouble here with rose rosette disease, though, and those bagged discount-store roses need very thorough looking-over. If even one in the store is showing symptoms, don't buy there, and wash your hands, clothes and shoes in hot water before going near your own roses again. Dry on "hot", too, to make sure any mites are dead. RRD is _devastating._ It'll kill your own roses, and can go on to those of your neighbors for a couple blocks around. It is not curable or even treatable. And then unless the soil is completely dug out and replaced, you and they will have to wait years to grow roses again.
Another of the bad vectors for the disease is the "Knockout" roses--yet another reason not to grow the damn things. :)
Reply #4 of 19 posted 3 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
If I see another Knock-out I'm going to puke. It's everywhere in the neighborhood. Walmart's parking lot had a bunch of them .. so glad they died over the winter.
Reply #5 of 19 posted 5 MAY 17 by Puns 'n' Roses
This is an earnest question, not meant as a provocation: What is it with Knock Out that makes people react so strongly and negatively ? I' ve read rose people a couple of times saying they hate it. I have never seen Knock Out knowingly - I've seen one rose of which I thought it might be Knock Out which was most impressive - so I'm not able to form my own opinion (yet). Many people seem to love it (obviously it's planted in lots of places), yet many don't. Why?
Reply #6 of 19 posted 5 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
The older RED single-petal knock-out is extremely thorny, ugly bush. The newer RED double-petal knock-out is more slender & compact. The PINK double-Knock-out doesn't have much thorns, but not as vigorous as the RED version. My neighbor was really mad when her PINK knock-out sprouted bright cherry-RED, it was actually grafted on a RED knock-out. It was not Dr.Huey, but actually a RED-knock-out as rootstock. She offered to me for FREE, but I already killed a bunch of my RED knock-outs.
Reply #7 of 19 posted 5 MAY 17 by Jay-Jay
Not all the rose-lovers detest prickles on a rose.
Knock Out roses have more to offer than being prickly.
As for continuous flowering, as for climate zonage and possibly as for breeding material for future Earth-kind roses.
Reply #8 of 19 posted 6 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
I have been growing these landscape roses for 17 years: 6 Knock-outs and 3 Flower Carpet roses. Knock-outs (both pink and red) need a HUGE amount of water to bloom, but break out in cerespora with acidic rain. Flower Carpet is way better than Knock-out. Flower Carpet blooms 1 month ahead of Knock-out in spring. Flower Carpet is drought-tolerant & better zone 5a winter survival & can handle spring flood. I never see any diseases in Flower Carpet's glossy foliage & way more blooms than Knock-outs.

Flower Carpets need less water to bloom than Knock-outs. Both rose parks (Cantigny with 1,200 roses) and Chicago Botanical garden (5,000 roses) got rid of their red-single-Knock-out: ugly bush shape. These parks still grow double-pink Knock-out (better bush shape & more flowers). Home Run is even stingier than Knock-out in blooms. Cantigny rose park got rid of Home run, only 1/10 the amount of blooms compared to Flower Carpet. For pictures of Flower Carpet at Chicago Botanical Garden, see the below link, which I took last spring:
Reply #9 of 19 posted 6 MAY 17 by Andrew from Dolton
Maybe they grow better in Europe?
BTW Straw, loved Chicago Botanic gardens, great pictures.
Reply #14 of 19 posted 9 MAY 17 by Fadi
I love my flower carpet yellow !
Absolutely beautiful!
No watering
No fertiliser
No disease
Flood tolerant ! Leafing out while practically setting
In water after spring snow melt and flood

Tolerant of heavy wet clay in Canada z5

Highly recommend
I also recommend the drift roses
Reply #15 of 19 posted 9 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
You mean "flower carpet amber"? Saw that at Lowe's for $10 in late fall (1/2 price), and the leaves were so pretty & glossy & perfect. The blooms were peachy yellow. Too bad I didn't buy it.
Reply #16 of 19 posted 9 MAY 17 by Fadi
I have the flower carpet yellow , red , scarlet, and pink supreme
I meant the flower carpet yellow , I planted 3 yellow together in a shady
area ( 3 hours of sun ) , the area is flooded in spring and wet during the summer
so no watering at all. The yellow grows tall and not bushy like the red or scarlet
I planted the pink supreme in fall last tea so it was dormant and I am looking to flower this year
I posted a picture of my flower carpet yellow on helpmefind

The leaves are very glossy and no disease at all in shade ; of course I would expect it to flower more in full sun
But I am really happy with the performance of yellow

I haven't seen the Amber but I would buy this if I still have a space
I have 2 drifts and I want to buy the apricot drift: very compact and hardy
Reply #17 of 19 posted 10 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
I saw your link ... so pretty !!
Reply #10 of 19 posted 6 MAY 17 by Nastarana
What it is about 'Knockout' is that it is, for many of us, a bland, boring rose with a dull color. In addition, the hype surrounding this rose was beyond annoying. What KO offers, an easy care, long blooming splash of color, has been in fact available for many years. Chinas and teas for the warmer zones, polyanthas and some of the floribundas for temperate gardens, and rugosas and some of the Canadian roses offer the same thing with much more attractive flowers.

Furthermore, what might be called landscape roses have also been available from at least around the mid-80s. The Flowercarpets from Noack (I think), the Meidillands and Drifts from Meilland and the low growing, bright roses from Ping Lim and Bear Creek all offer a better, IMHO, version of what you get from the KOs. I grow both 'White Meidilland' and 'Alba Meidilland'; both are perfectly cane hardy in zone 5, have far more beautiful flowers than, e.g.. 'White Out'. I consider 'Alba Meidilland', an ever blooming rambler, to be in fact a great rose, to be ranked with such classics as 'Peace' and 'Mr. Lincoln'.

Having said all that, what I am excited about from Mr. Radler is the larger bushes, like 'Milwaukee Calatrava' and climbers he is working on now.
Reply #11 of 19 posted 7 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
Very well written, Nastarana. THANK YOU. There's the myth of "blackspot-resistant-strain" which made Knock-out famous. Drift roses can do what Knock-out cannot do: stay healthy in flood zone. My neighbor's Drift roses get bigger as they get older, while her 30+ Knock-out shrank due to poor winter-survival.

Val who works for decades at a landscape company in warm Florida, zone 8b, gave THUMB-DOWN for Knock-out, for the same reason: cerespora fungal-disease from rain, plus not blooming well in hot & dry spell.

Chicago botanical garden has a large tree, which they planted dozens of light pink & double Flower Carpet in a circle next to the tree. There were more blooms than leaves on those roses, despite being planted ON TOP of tree's root & partial shade. Flower Carpet can easily get the "more blooms than leaves" look, but Knock-out cannot, unless it's week-long rain. See below link pictures of Drift roses, Flower Carpet, and Ping-Lim roses at Cantigny Rose Park, which I took near my alkaline clay, zone 5a. Rainbow Knock-out was the worst-looking among their 1,000+ landscape bushes:
Reply #12 of 19 posted 8 MAY 17 by Blue Zinnia
Also, KO (1.) is ugly between flushes, (2.) has virtually no fragrance, (3.) sets no fruit, and (4.) has squeezed most or all other roses out of a lot of garden centers. Personally, I don't find the color dull, and I do like the look of an established KO in full bloom. But there are just too many good reasons to hate them...not least that the landlady's KO's rose rosette disease (for which KOs are an absolute magnet) took out my best-ever, really glorious plant of my alltime favorite hybrid tea, Kordes Perfecta, and made it impossible for us to grow roses here for years on.
Reply #18 of 19 posted 21 MAY 17 by StrawChicago Alkaline clay 5a
The use of chemical fertilizer high in nitrogen do attract pests (including RRD mites). There are many studies that show high nitrogen attract pests. When the natural environment is altered with chemicals, that invite pathogenic pests. When a rose is weakened with acidity (either from acidic soil, or acidic rain, or acidic fertilziers), pests can take over. If you google "pH of rain across USA, you'll see a pH of 4.5 for my Chicagoland, and even lower for the east coast.

Re-post the info. I gave: "HMF is the best source for info., but I wish folks would specify their soil & climate & planting zone & what region of the country. People want to hold on to "old generalizations", rather than learning. Like nearby rose park, I was shocked to see them dumping sulfur in spring ... they burnt Tamora (prefers alkaline), also induced RRD (rose rosette disease) on Pink Traviata (Meilland rose) which also prefers alkaline. Gypsum is also acidic, I killed lots of earthworms using that stuff, and it burns my finger. Gypsum has calcium plus sulfur.

I made the same mistake years ago: dumping sulfur plus high nitrogen chemical fertilizer on a Grandma' Blessing rose, changing my soil pH to very acidic. It immediately came down with RRD five years ago. That's the ONLY rose with RRD in my 30+ years of growing roses, among 100+ varieties. I planted Radio Times in the exact spot, but I raised the pH with more alkaline clay, and no RRD ever since. I wish folks would stop generalizations, "Mr. Lincoln for fragrant reds", "roses prefer acidic", and "roses need full-sun". Own-root roses are completely different from each other.
Reply #19 of 19 posted 28 DEC by Blue Zinnia
Hmmm....our rain here is mildly acidic, but not enough to wreck the soil pH, which I checked. And nothing got dumped on my Kordes Perfecta but good old Black Cow; the landlady's KO didn't even get that. RRD is spread by a mite, and if significant numbers of the mites are around, the roses in the area are likely to get it, despite decent pH and no chemicals. Sucks, but there it is.
Reply #13 of 19 posted 8 MAY 17 by Blue Zinnia
Also, there's Bonica, which is beautiful, tough, floriferous over a very long season, reasonably fragrant, and genuinely healthy, and which sets good hips, Royal Bonica is also excellent.

And then there are the Griffith Buck roses, many of which are shrubby (see Carefree Beauty, among others) and nearly all of which are tough, lovely, floriferous, hardy, and healthy. Most are at least somewhat fragrant.
Discussion id : 46-743
most recent 4 AUG 15 SHOW ALL
Initial post 13 JUL 10 by Rosaholic's Southern California Garden
This one is advertised as highly fragrant, scented of licorice. I don't detect that fragrance at all, and very little other fragrance.
Reply #1 of 3 posted 21 MAY 11 by Michael Garhart
I smelled it last year. It had a strong, very odd scent to me. I couldnt place the scent type, other than "odd".
Reply #2 of 3 posted 12 MAR 15 by LonRob
You must have received a mislabeled plant. Our is heavenly scented and swarms of flowers from spring through the fall. It's great! Sorry you did not experience it.
Reply #3 of 3 posted 4 AUG 15 by Michael Garhart
It was from the huge display at Washington Park. I think its somewhere between sweet and myrrh.
Discussion id : 67-646
most recent 9 MAR 14 SHOW ALL
Initial post 17 OCT 12 by Joseph Baiocchi
This is the first year with this rose - own root growing in a 5 gallon pot. While I was a little disappointed that it is definitely NOT white, the plant has been a wonderful surprise. It is mannerly, covered in wonderful foliage, and pumps out flush after flush. The fragrance is moderate and reminicent of licorice. I did not spray at all this year, and there was not hint of disease on it.

I would not compare this rose to Julia Child. The comparison is unfair. They are very different plants and I would expect to use them in very different circumstances. JC has a tendency to outgrow its space and get taller than I would like, this rose does not. Placed with HTs of medium height, grew happlily in its appointed spot - of couse next year, when we move it up to a larger pot, will be the real test of that. While JC has a very strong lasting yellow, the yelllow in the rose is muted (not unexpected as it is advertised as white) and fades significantly. The flowers are much more formal than JC, but not really high centered. I think this plant could produce exhibition quality flowers if planted in good soil in the ground and fed generously.

As someone who is not fond of yellow roses (I only have three), This rose has been a real surprise and I find I like it more each time I see it. If planted in the right place and with the the right expectations it really does shine in the garden.
Reply #1 of 1 posted 9 MAR 14 by Ranger6
very helpful comments. Thank you.
Discussion id : 72-437
most recent 26 JUL 13 SHOW ALL
Initial post 18 JUN 13 by Robert D.
Beautiful plant, beautiful scent and beautiful flower. Period!

Update on 7/15/2013: This rose was absolutely unscathed during our recent 10-day heat wave during which temperatures ranged between 97 and 110 each and every day. So many of our other roses suffered burning, and some look like they were torched. This one looks and smells as fresh as always, blooming up a storm! We may get a few more just to have this delightful rose available to us at all time as a cut rose. Simply wonderful! A few others that did well during this period were Barbara Streisand, Touch of Class, Marmalade Skies, Gemini and Sun Flare. We have about 50 rose bushes right now from a climber down to a couple of micro minis. All these others suffered some degree of burning and acute stress. We hope the worst of the weather (which was unusually hot for our region) is over. Our garden and the many birds who live around our garden were acutely stressed. Thank goodness our water didn't go off during this period!

Take care everyone.
Reply #1 of 1 posted 26 JUL 13 by BamaPC
This one does make a great cut flower. I was very surprised at its vase life. I don't recall ever having a floribunda that lasted so long cut. It outlasts a lot of my HTs.
© 2018