HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
Search PostsPosts By CategoryRecent Posts 
Questions, Answers and Comments by Category
Discussion id : 111-671
most recent today HIDE POSTS
Initial post today by Michael Garhart
Year 4. It's blooming now. Going to compost it soon. The other "European orange HT/GR types" I have that are younger are out-performing it in bloom amount and color retention.

Namely Halle, Dronning Ingrid (and Remember Me, but its older here).

Even my virused clone of 'Marina' outperforms it, and the blooms are the same size.

And from North America: Louise Hay.
Discussion id : 111-646
most recent yesterday HIDE POSTS
Initial post yesterday by HubertG
From J. Steckler's Seeds Co almanac 1905, page 134

"Mme. Derepas Matrat.; Yellow Cochet. A pure Tea rose, very free-growing and hardy in character, withstanding ten degrees below zero. It throws up fine, strong stems, crowned by solitary buds of grand size; the color is a good sulphur-yellow, blooms very large, perfectly double, splendid form and freely produced. It has every quality necessary to make the ideal yellow bedder, ranking with the White and Pink Cochets in value as a Summer rose"
Reply #1 of 1 posted yesterday by Patricia Routley
Thanks HubertG. Added. I have also added the 1914 Leedle ref and they didn't like it much.
Discussion id : 111-627
most recent today HIDE POSTS
Initial post yesterday by HubertG
The description page for 'Alexander Hill Gray' says "sets no hips". I've always found mine sets hips (which hold seeds) fairly readily. I find this a bit puzzling.
Reply #1 of 10 posted yesterday by HMF Admin
And this is exactly why comments like yours are so useful and what makes HMF so special. At some point in time, a permanent reference indicated otherwise and now we know that reference is in question based on your experience.

We need more people take the time to share their experience - Thanks !
Reply #2 of 10 posted yesterday by Patricia Routley
I certainly wouldn't discount that reference Admin. What we need is more of them to say if this rose does, or does not set hips. The fact that we show just one 1922 descendant indicates that it does not, and therefore there is a possibility that HubertG has received a rose other than 'Alexander Hill Gray'. Every reference is valuable.
Reply #3 of 10 posted yesterday by HubertG
Thanks HMF Admin,
This site is a veritable commonwealth of rose knowledge; the more contributions the better.

Patricia, I have two bushes of AHG ordered from different nurseries maybe 5 years apart. They are both the same and both do set hips. They do look the same as other AHGs in Australia posted here (I've posted a few photos of mine too) This is a double rose but not what I'd call a full one and so they have normal looking reproductive parts and, if insects can get in, I can't see any reason (barring an odd ploidy) why it shouldn't set hips. That's why I thought the no hips reference was unusual. By the time AHG was introduced Teas were waning in popularity, so that is probably the likeliest reason it wasn't used much in breeding, in my opinion.
Reply #4 of 10 posted yesterday by HubertG
There are in fact a couple of hips on Margaret Furness' photo here:
Reply #5 of 10 posted yesterday by Patricia Routley
That is interesting HubertG. They are hard to see, but I do see them.
I suspect Margaret didn't note them as she has said in her more recent photo 315211 that her plant didn't set hips.
Unfortunately 'Alexander Hill Gray' never came my way, so I have no first-hand experience. How else can I help here?
Reply #6 of 10 posted yesterday by HubertG
Best to wait for more comments on this topic, I'd say.
Reply #7 of 10 posted yesterday by Margaret Furness
Maybe it varies with how the weather has been. There's nothing on mine now that I would call a hip. It doesn't flower much in a dry summer.
Reply #8 of 10 posted yesterday by billy teabag
Do your 'Alexander Hill Gray' plants have prickles HubertG?
Reply #9 of 10 posted yesterday by HubertG
No, it's virtually thornless. I took some photos this morning of a few hips on one of my AHGs, which I'll post later.

Its thornlessness was the reason I had previously questioned whether it might have in fact been Mme Derepas-Metrat, one of the other "Yellow Cochets", because that was nearly thornless according to references, and thornlessness is a rarity in early roses.
Reply #10 of 10 posted today by HubertG
There were five hips on one of my plants this morning. I didn't check the other plant. The split hip is one I collected about April, showing the seeds. I do think the weather conditions play a part; AHG does tend to ball a bit, so if it doesn't open, it won't become fertilised.
Discussion id : 96-180
most recent today SHOW ALL
Initial post 4 DEC 16 by CybeRose
American Rose Annual vol. 1, p. 124 (1916)
Roses Hybridized by E. G. Hill
Robert Heller, T. 1911
Reply #1 of 4 posted 5 DEC 16 by Patricia Routley
They began to call it a HT in later refs.
Reply #2 of 4 posted yesterday by HubertG
From the Leedle Floral Co. 1914 Fall catalogue, page 34:

"Robert Heller - (Heller, 1911) (T.) Deep golden-yellow; a seedling from Perle des Jardins, deeper in color and stronger in growth. A constant summer bloomer, vigorous, thrifty and one of the most brilliant and beautifully formed yellow Roses yet introduced."
Reply #3 of 4 posted yesterday by Patricia Routley
Thanks to you both. Hill or Heller I wonder. i note Karl's photo says introduced by Heller.
Reply #4 of 4 posted today by HubertG
'Robert Heller' seems to be named after the nurseryman's son, and seems to be a counterpart for the rose 'Jeanette Heller' named for his daughter. 'Jeanette Heller' of course is the rose involved in the infamous 'W.R.Smith' mixup debacle, and wasn't bred by Heller. By best guess is that 'Robert Heller' is a rose bred by Hill and Heller had (or again thought he had) the naming rights. Perhaps there is another named yellow rose by Hill which is the same as 'Robert Heller'.
© 2018