Book  (1936)  Page(s) 461.  
 
Marx (pimpinellifolia) Cartier ca. 1825; sulphur-yellow, small, double, fine form, cordiform petals, solitary, fragrance 5/10 (lemon), floriferous, many yellowish prickles, distant branches, small dainty Habit.

Book  (1899)  Page(s) 126.  
 
Marx, Pimpinellifolia, Catier, soufre

Book  (1838)  Page(s) 136.  
 
Rosa. Spinosissima. Burnet-leafed Rose. Scotch Rose. Rosa Dumensis. Rosa Campestris Odora. Rosa Prœcox Spinosa. Rosa Pimpinellifolia.
Yellowish Flowers.
11. Marx.
Shrub, small and elegant.
Branches, divergent, armed.
Thorns, numerous, yellowish, fine, uneven, rather crooked.
Leaves, nine leaflets.
Leaflets, small, almost round, finely toothed.
Flowers, small, well formed, sulphur-yellow, numerous, solitary, lemon-scented.
Petals, heart-shaped, or irregularly shaped.