Magazine  (Jul 1875)  Page(s) 113.  
 
Variétés odorantes, mais moins que les précédentes.
5° Roses Hybrides remontantes. Achille Gonod. Adolphe Brongniart. Alpaïde de Rotalier. Auguste Rigotard. Baronne de Claparède.  Baronne Prévost. Bernard Palissy. Caroline de Sansal. Cécile de Chabrillant. Charles Margottin. Charles Verdier. Charles Turner. Clémence Joigneaux. Comte de Nanteuil. Comtesse de Jaucourt. Duchesse de Cambacérés. Duchesse de Norfolk. Edouard Morren. Eugène Sue. François premier. Général Changarnier. Général  Washington. Gloire de Santenay. Jacques Lafitte. Jean Goujon. Jules Margottin. La France. La Reine. Léopold I^er. Léopold II. Madame Alice Dureau. Madame Campbell d'Islay. Madame Charles Verdier. Madame De Ridder. Madame  Domage. Madame Furtado. Mad. Jacquin. Mad. Knorr. Mad. Moreau. Mad. Rivers. Maréchal Suchet. Maréchal Vaillant. Marguerite Dombrain. Marquise de Castellane. Noémi. Ordéric Vital. Perfection de Lyon. Pierre Notting. Président Mas. Prince Humbert. Souvenir de Poiteau. Sydonie. Triomphe de l'Exposition.Ville de S^t-Denis.

Book  (1875)  Page(s) 83.  
 
The Hybrid Perpetual Rose.
Adelaide de Rotalier: silvery-pink, flowers large, full, and well formed, having large smooth outer petals; habit robust.

Errata.
Page 83  Adelaide de Rotalier, should be Alpaide de Rotalier.

Magazine  (23 Mar 1867)  Page(s) 121.  
 
"Roses and the frost at Stamford" by Charles Laxton
During the nights of the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th of January my thermometer registered here, in a walled garden at five feet from the ground, and in the open, 23°, 21°, 22°, and 22° of frost respectively... The snow here froze on the branches, and was three inches deep on the ground.... My list of uninjured (No. 1) may therefore be relied upon as containing only thoroughly hardy sorts.
Hybrid Perpetuals
Alpaide de Rotalier

Book  (1866)  Page(s) 151.  
 
Rosa bifera hybrida — Rose hybride remontante.
Alphaide de Rotalier (Rosomene),  Blumen groß, gefüllt, sehr schön gebaut, durchsichtig hellrosa.  Zur Bildung von niedrigen Gruppen geeignet.

Translation:  Hybrid Perpetual.
Alphaide de Rotalier (Rosomene family).  The flowers are large, full, very well formed, a transparent light pink.  Suitable for massing.

Book  (1866)  Page(s) 210.  
 
Hybrid Perpetual Roses.
Alpaide de Rotalier, fine transparent rose-color, glossy, large, full, and of good form.

Website/Catalog  (1866)  
 
Alpaide de Rotalier HP. Clear silvery pink, beautiful and distinct. 

Magazine  (Jul 1865)  Page(s) 202.  
 
Une Proménade au Milieu des Roses.
Alpaïde de Rotalier, fleur grande, imbriquée, rose satiné transparent.

A Stroll Amongst the Roses.
Alpaïde de Rotalier, the large, imbricated flower is a transparent satin pink.

Website/Catalog  (1865)  Page(s) 35.  
 
Rosa hybrida bifera. — Remontant-Rose. — Hybride remontant.
9*  Alpaïde de Rotalier (Campy).  Kraftig, Blume schön hellrosa, seidenartig, gefüllt und schön gebaut.

Translation:  Hybrid Perpetual.
Alpaïde de Rotalier (Campy).  Vigorous, the flower is a beautiful light satin-pink, full and beautifully formed.

Magazine  (Oct 1864)  Page(s) 213.  
 
Roses in 1864.
Among reds and various shades of rose colour there are also a few gems. Alpaide de Rotalier is a distinct and lovely rose, the colour silvery pink, the flowers large and well formed, and the habit free and robust.

Magazine  (20 Oct 1863)  Page(s) 306-7.  
 
New Roses.
...And now for the Hybrid Perpetuals.  We will take them according to the raisers.
Charles Verdier.
1.  Alpaide de Rotalier (Campy), transparent satin rose.
2.  Alphonse Belin (Gautreau), clear brilliant red.
3.  Joseph Durand (Ledéchaux), slaty, shaded red.
4.  Triomphe de Villecresnes (Ledéchaux), clear vivid red.
5.  Leopold Roi des Belges, clear velvety red.
Of these, none of which were raised by Mons. Verdier, 1 obtained a prize at the Floral Committee (Comité de Floriculture) of the Société Impériale et Centrale, at Paris in July, 1862; and 5, a prize at Brussels in the same month.  3 is not full enough.  2 has the under side of the petals a different colour- a decided blemish to my mind; while 4 seems from description to be good, a seedling of Triomphe de l'Exposition.  Of 1, 4, and 5, then, we may entertain reasonable hopes.