These photos are probably correct, while the photo at Vintage Gardens website seems to show Vibert's "Arlequin". These photos show larger more mottled petals, almost like a rugosa rose. The Vibert "Arlequin" is smoother in coloring, has smaller petals, and a green "eye". There is one photo at Dave's Garden of the Vintage Gardens rose (by Vibert, and not Paillard as he has recorded in his listing.)