Book  (2012)  Page(s) 43.  
 
Rosiers de Provins
1ère Série.
R. Athalie id [Vibert]

Book  (Jul 1998)  Page(s) 305.  
 
Athalie Gallica. Vibert. Included in the collection of the Luxembourg Garden around 1852-1860.

Book  (Jul 1998)  Page(s) 83.  
 
Fanny Bias ....Besides, the synonym "Athalie", used particularly by Pépinières Baltet, should not be confused with the gallica "Athalie" which Vibert obtained in 1823 (also extinct).

Book  (1899)  Page(s) 15.  
 
Athalie, Provins, Vibert, rose foncé

Book  (1880)  Page(s) Annex, p. 12.  
 
gallica, Athalie, deep pink, large, double.

Book  (1858)  Page(s) 202.  
 
Rosa gallica.
Athalie, Blumen groß, gefüllt, dunkelrosenroth.

Translation: Rosa gallica.
Athalie, the large, double flowers are a deep rose color.

Book  (1848)  Page(s) Book 2, p. 43.  
 
Gallica. ATHALIE; flowers cherry-red, occasionally shaded with purple, lively, very large and double; form, expanded. An abundant bloomer, very showy. Habit, branching; growth, moderate. A good seed-bearer.

Website/Catalog  (1844)  Page(s) 9.  
 
Provins Athalie.

Book  (1838)  Page(s) 66.  
 
Gallica. Athalie. Very beautiful, good fragrance. Blooms beautiful rose-pink, becomes later somewhat bluish, 2 1/2 in., double, flat.

Book  (1837)  Page(s) 62.  
 
Rosiers de Provins
1ère Série.
R. Athalie id [Vibert]