HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
'Prima Ballerina ®' rose Reviews & Comments
Discussion id : 133-987
most recent today SHOW ALL
 
Initial post 3 AUG 22 by Hamanasu
Would anyone growing this rose care to describe its scent? Is it citrusy, fruity/peachy, quintessentially rose, licorice-like, tea-like, clove-like, or something else? If you could compare it to other well-scented roses you grow, that would help. This is one of Fragrant Cloud's parents and the other parent (I think) was not known for its strong scent, so chances are PB is primarily responsible for FC's fragrance. OK, it might not be that simple, I guess, but is PB's scent similar to FC's?
REPLY
Reply #1 of 5 posted 27 JAN by HeelinRoses
deleted
REPLY
Reply #2 of 5 posted yesterday by HeelinRoses
I'm growing Prima Ballerina for the first time this year and I would say it has an average scent although it's fairly noticeable and a bit sweet when sniffed. Not especially fruity or exciting and I don't recommend the plant.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 5 posted today by Hamanasu
Thank you for taking the time to respond. Much appreciated.
REPLY
Reply #4 of 5 posted today by HubertG
Tantau, in their 1957 catalogue when it was introduced, describe 'Prima Ballerina' as strongly scented ("die stark duftende Blume") and that "Der Duft schwebt so intensiv über ihr, daß eine Vase mit dieser Neuheit im Zimmer sie schon von weitem ankündigt." (the scent wafts so intensively around it that a vase of this novelty in a room announces it from a distance). So, no mention of the quality of the scent apart from strength, but it does sound pretty strong.
REPLY
Reply #5 of 5 posted today by Hamanasu
Thank you. Indeed, many sources mention a strong scent, though your quote is interesting in singling it out as exceptional. I am still intrigued about what it smells of. Perhaps some other users will chime in.
REPLY
Reply #6 of 5 posted today by HeelinRoses
Jack Leigh Harkness in his book 'Roses' said he'd have given Prima Ballerina a 10/10 for fragrance but he only gave its offspring 'Fragrant Cloud' a 9. Personally, I prefer 'Fragrant Cloud' - a good wafter in the garden but even so not my favourite rose to sniff.
I've been a little disappointed with PB. The flowers, unlike what I had expected (though there were copious amounts of them) didn't appear to be useful to bees, they looked pale, unspectacular and didn't have a very pronounced fragrance. To me it was more like an odour, sweet granted but something that you might find in a detergent or bathroom product. If you like those kinds of smells then I heartily recommend 'Mum in a Million' over PB. 'Mum in a Million' is a much better plant and its scent is complex and interesting.
'Reconciliation' by Harkness - now that has a beautiful smell - something like a freshly opened ripe corn cob with sweet rose, apricots and cloves.
'Caprice de Meilland'/'Best Friend' also has a clear, distinctive fruity smell - raspberry and blackcurrant.
'Fragrant Plum' one of my faves, smells at its best in early Summer and late Autumn (here in the UK) when the flowers are darker.
I have yet to test Prima Ballerina in the vase, to discover how pervasive her scent is, we're only in July but there don't appear to be any any flowers left to try out.
My favourite rose for fragrance in the vase is the mystery one which I'm trying to identify - please see my comments on the 'Rosenresli' (by Kordes) pages and the 'Norma Major' pages, HMF.
REPLY
Discussion id : 172-405
most recent 18 APR HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 18 APR by HeelinRoses
Deleted
REPLY
Discussion id : 170-486
most recent 27 JAN HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 27 JAN by HeelinRoses
On a website called 'thegardenoxford.co.uk' is a photo of a Prima Ballerina plant label which says that this rose got the RNRS President's Trophy in 1989 and a Gold Medal from Glasgow (but it doesn't say what year).
Could readers of the RNRS Annuals look into this to confirm?
If true then it ought to be added to the Awards.
Also elsewhere I saw the breeder's name 'TANprall'
REPLY
Reply #1 of 0 posted 27 JAN by jedmar
According to HMF's records the 1989 PIT was won by 'Pretty Polly' of Meilland. 'Prima Ballerina' was from 1957 - 30 years after introduction seems to far for an award. Information from the Rose Annuals would be valuable.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 0 posted 27 JAN by HeelinRoses
delete
REPLY
Discussion id : 170-482
most recent 27 JAN HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 27 JAN by HeelinRoses
deleted
REPLY
Reply #1 of 0 posted 27 JAN by jedmar
Tan01687 is listed on Tantau's patent and trademark list
REPLY
Reply #2 of 0 posted 27 JAN by HeelinRoses
deleted
REPLY
© 2025 HelpMeFind.com