Book  (1936)  Page(s) 562.  
 
Phoenix (Provins) Vibert 1843; pink to carmine with lilac reflexes, large, very double, fragrance 6/10, once-blooming, growth 8/10, climbing, 1.50 m = Lyre de Flore. Sangerhausen

Book  (1902)  Page(s) 103.  
 
[Among the roses grown at L'Haÿ in 1902.] No. 3043 (Vibert 1843) rose et carm.

Book  (1899)  Page(s) 143.  
 
Phoenix, Provins, Vibert, 1843, rose et carmin, syn. Lyre de Flore

Book  (1842)  Page(s) 272.  
 
R. gallica....Varieties....with flesh-coloured or pink blooms...Phoenix, beautiful pink, early