Book  (1990)  Page(s) 39.  
 
Mme. Ville Gallica. Raiser unknown. Description... bright carmine-pink...

Book  (1936)  Page(s) 737.  
 
Ville, Mme. (Provins) ? ? ; vivid carmine, medium size, double.

Book  (1899)  Page(s) 117.  
 
Madame Ville, Provins, carmin

Book  (1880)  Page(s) Annex, p. 86.  
 
gallica. Madame Ville, fiery carmine, medium size, full.

Book  (1858)  Page(s) 215.  
 
Rosa gallica.
Madame Ville, Blumen mittelgroß, voll, feurig carmoisin.

Translation: Rosa gallica.
Madame Ville, the medium-sized, full flowers are a fiery crimson.

Website/Catalog  (1846)  Page(s) 61.  
 
Rosiers Provins.
Madame Ville, cramoisi feu...2 fr.

Book  (1846)  Page(s) 603.  
 
Rosiers provins.
Madame Ville...