Book  (2020)  Page(s) 151.  
 
Erroneously named and unidentified rose varieties at the Europa-Rosarium.
Gallica... 'Thalie la Gentille' (Descemet?, before 1811)

Book  (Mar 1999)  Page(s) 103.  
 
France 1800s. Origin and date are unknown. Description. Flowers: Very double, quartered, green button eye, rose-pink. Grown at Malmaison.

Book  (Jul 1998)  Page(s) 109-110.  
 
Thalie la Gentille Descemet (?), before 1811.
Synonyms: Thalie (according to Prévost, 1824).
Habit: Upright, strong branches; crooked and pointed prickles; can get taller than 2 m. Foliage: light, elliptical leaflets; quite large, edged with a fine red border when young. Bloom: medium size, rarely solitary, more often in clusters of 3 or 4, sometimes 6 or 7, very double, cupped, quartered, reddish central eye, passing to light green. Colour: deep carmine-pink, veined, lighter on the outer petals. Fragrance: very strong.
References: Guerrapain (1811), p. 29; Le Rouge (1819), p. 68; Prévost, catal. 1824, no. 625, catal. 1829, no. 254. Bibliography: Jacob et al. p. 96. Trade: Yes, but rare. Collections: author, Gap-Charance, L'Haÿ, Malmaison, Sangerhausen.
In 1811 Guerrapain described 'Thalie la gentille' as follows: "This rose resembles its sister and companion 'Euphrosine' in form and twisting; but it is smaller, of a more soft red; it is as fragrant, blooms at the same period. One finds the same similarities in the wood and the foliage."
In his catalogue of 1829, Prévost calls this rose 'Thalie', classes it as a damask and notes that it is found in the nursery of Vibert. The classification as a Damask is easily understandable, as 'Thalie la gentille' is probably a hybrid of gallica and damask (as Le Rouge also points out in 1819).
The fact that Guerrapain considers 'Thalie la gentille' and 'Euphrosine l'élégante' as sisters and companions lets us think that the former is probably an introduction of Descement as the second. It is from Descemet that Vibert, his successor, has quite naturally obtained 'Thalie la gentille'. Their similarity has likley led Descemet to give both the names of two of the "Three Graces"; these names from Antiquity are quite in his manner. Very logically, Gravereaux has estimated that 'Thalie la gentille' was found at Malmaison during the time of Joséphine: it was recently re-established there....

Book  (1993)  Page(s) 33.  Includes photo(s).
 
Gallica hybrid, possibly a Gallica x Damask. Description.

Book  (1936)  Page(s) 700.  
 
Thalie (damask) Vibert 1819; purple-pink, small, double, many straight prickles, with silky bristles

Book  (1846)  Page(s) 26.  
 
Other once-blooming Roses....Alba Thalie, magnificent, good fragrance. Soft pink, 2 inches wide, double.

Book  (1829)  Page(s) 84.  
 
Rosa damascena....Hybrides....
254. Thalie , V. [Vibert] Rameaux hérissés de nombreux aiguillons inégaux , ordinairement droits, entremêlés de soies. Folioles veinées ridées , velues des deux côtés. Ovaire , turbiné, très court, hispide-glanduleux. Fleur petite, pleine, rose
purpurin.

Book  (1828)  Page(s) 71.  
 
Rosier de Francfort..
1752. _Thalie (Vibert, 1819).

Website/Catalog  (1826)  Page(s) 38.  
 
Roses de Francfort.
118 Thalie...Année de la première floraisom: 1819.

Website/Catalog  (1820)  Page(s) 48.  
 
Hybrides et variétés incertaines. No. 823 Thalie, 1819