Book  (Apr 1999)  Page(s) 506.  
 
Dieudonné Hybrid China. Paillard, pre-1828.

Book  (1936)  Page(s) 210.  
 
Dieudonné (hybrid china) Paillard ? ; velvety dark violet, small to medium size, semi double = Rose paillard

Book  (1936)  Page(s) 738.  
 
Vineux (hybrid china) Cugnot ca. 1825; velvety dark violet, medium size, semi-double, slender branches

Book  (1936)  Page(s) 536.  
 
Paillard, Rose (hybrid china) Vibert ca. 1835; dark violet

Book  (1899)  Page(s) 50.  
 
Dieudonné, Hyride de Bengale, Paillard, violet foncé

Book  (1899)  Page(s) 178.  
 
Vineux, Hybride de Bengale, Cugnot, violet foncé

Book  (1899)  Page(s) 139.  
 
Paillard, Bengale, Vibert, pourpre violet

Book  (1838)  Page(s) 337.  
 
Hybrid Bengal Roses
Le Vineux. Bengal Dieudonné. Rose Paillard. Branches, slender. Flowerstalks, hispid and glandulous. Tube of calyx, smooth, oval-pyriform. Flowers, middle-sized, semi-double, of a deep velvety violet.

Book  (1837)  Page(s) Sect. III, p. 34.  
 
Hybrid Chinas...Pailardrose, not worth much, little fragrance, if there is not a mixup here. Pink-flesh-coloured, only 1 1/2 inch wide, double.

Book  (1837)  Page(s) Sect. III, p. 59.  
 
Hybrid Chinas...Uncertain and all not yet listed colours....Pailard violacé, very beautiful, mild fragrance. Velvety dark violet, 2 inches wide, semi-double.