Book  (Apr 1999)  Page(s) 38.  
 
Columelle ('Columella') Gallica. Vibert 1841. The author cites information from different sources... crimson purple... A deep, bright pink, shaded with flush on the margins of the petals...

Book  (1936)  Page(s) 167.  
 
Columella (Provins) ? before 1850; carmine-pink, shaded crimson, large, double, dense habit

Book  (1880)  Page(s) Annex, p. 30.  
 
gallica. Columelle, purple-carmine, large, full.

Book  (1858)  Page(s) 206.  
 
Rosa gallica.
Columelle, Blumen groß, voll, purpur carmoisin.

Translation: Rosa gallica.
Columelle, the large, full flowers are crimson-purple.

Book  (1849)  Page(s) 580.  
 
Rosa gallica. Newer, select varieties with double blooms...with carmine-red, purple-red and other red roses....Columelle, large, purple-crimson

Magazine  (1848)  Page(s) 238.  
 
Gallica or French.- Boule de Nantieul, Columella, Duc de Trevise, D'Aguesseau, Kean, and Cambrone.

Book  (1848)  Page(s) 13.  
 
Among [Monsieur Vibert's] more modern varieties, he enumerates Yolande d'Aragon, Princesse Clémentine, Eugène Duboys Dessauzais, Pluto, Feu Brillante, Columelle, Eliza Mercoeur, Comtesse Murinais, Alice Leroi, Semiramis, la Négresse, and numerous others of which the merit is doubtful, or to which sufficient time has not been given to prove their various properties.

Book  (1847)  Page(s) 548.  
 
Rosier de Provins. Rosa Gallica.
Variétés jardinières.
Columelle. Fleurs grandes, pleines, pourpre-cramoisi.

Website/Catalog  (1846)  Page(s) 60.  
 
Rosiers Provins.
Columelle, grande, pleine, pourpre cramoisi..1 25 fr.

Book  (1846)  Page(s) 602.  
 
Rosiers provins.
Columelle...