HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
    DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
    "Plaisance Pink" rose Reviews & Comments
    most recent 30 MAY 18  
    Rose"Plaisance Pink"
    Initial post 4 JUN 15 by AquaEyes
    I happened upon this found Tea via the facebook page for "Roses Anciennes -- Vintage Roses", which seems to bear some resemblance to another found rose here in the US. Please compare to "Thomasville Old Told". Thoughts?

    http://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.6257.0

    :-)

    ~Christopher
    Reply #1 posted 4 AUG 15 by kai-eric
    so many varieties can look similar. unfortunally, we are lacking better pictures and detailled descriptions of this one.
    Reply #2 posted 4 AUG 15 by AquaEyes
    On an antique roses forum, this thread was posted about an unidentified rose in Spain. The found rose "Isabella Ducrot" was also mentioned as a possibility. It would be very interesting to compare the various "sunset-colored" Teas like these, and 'Clementina Carbonieri', and 'Isabella Nabonnand', etc. I'd wager that there's a duplicate somewhere among them.

    http://forums.gardenweb.com/discussions/1605176/identify-this?n=46

    :-)

    ~Christopher
    Reply #4 posted 27 MAY 18 by AmiRoses
    I have both "Isabella Ducrot" and "Plaisance Pink", they are different. "Isabella Ducrot" is much more changing.
    Reply #5 posted 27 MAY 18 by Patricia Routley
    Thanks AmiRoses. I have added your notes to the main pages for the roses.
    Reply #3 posted 27 MAY 18 by AmiRoses
    "Thomasville Old Gold" flower is much bigger
    Reply #6 posted 29 MAY 18 by HubertG
    Does 'Luciole' from 1886 sound like it could be a possibility? 'Luciole' was described as having a strong fragrance. Does "Plaisance Pink" have a good fragrance?
    Reply #7 posted 30 MAY 18 by HubertG
    This is also an interesting reference to 'Luciole' - "flower stem roughened like a moss-rose; "- from the 1888 Hill & co catalogue, considering that the photo (ID 317246) of "Plaisance Pink" shows a rather hispid stem.