HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
'Boule de Neige' rose Reviews & Comments
Discussion id : 133-981
most recent 9 days ago HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 9 days ago by Little Annie
Hi. Just became a member and I have a question. I grew some roses many years ago and want to start growing them again. I'm very interested in two bourbons and cannot make up my mind as to which one. First, Mme. Earnest Calvat or Boule de Neige. I'm in northeastern Ohio, zone 5b and I want very fragrant roses. I love both roses forms, but, I've read that BdN is not very fragrant, yet, it is disease resistant, where MEC is not. I've done as much reading as I can find on both roses. Can anyone growing BdN give me any information on it's scent and the strength of it? I would sure appreciate it as BdN is a more practical rose for me, but, if it's not very fragrant I will pass it up.
REPLY
Discussion id : 127-849
most recent 30 MAY 21 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 28 MAY 21 by Lesky
Rose Petals Nursery is currently carrying this rose. I bought one from them in 2019 but it appears to be a mislabeled plant of Madame Plantier.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 2 posted 29 MAY 21 by Nastarana
Those wondrous Lacharme hybrids from an extinct Damask perpetual named 'Sappho' and a Bourbon (or Noisette, as some would have it) are, alas, almost all out of commerce now in North America.

I am fascinated to learn that you can grow BdN in zone 5b; would you mind telling us something about its' site, and how much winter protection it needs?
REPLY
Reply #2 of 2 posted 30 MAY 21 by Lesky
I am updating my response. After making a comparison to my 'Boule de Neige' to a plant I have of Madame Plantier, which is 2 years old and just blooming this year, I realize the two appear to be one and the same--I believe my BdN was mislabeled and, as I had no previous experience with it or MP, didn't question it until now. I very much like the rose, but I apologize for misleading anyone that it was an noteworthy and successful Boule de Neige!

I did previously mention that Hummingbird Roses in northern Michigan has BdN on her list-it so happened that I was able to physically visit her and verified that her parent plant of BdN is definitely more like the descriptions and character that I had read, with shiny, larger, darker green coloring in the foliage and a less lanky habit than what I have growing. In doublechecking, I saw a photo here from May of 2013 of a plant that was labeled BdN but questioned by knowledgeable rosarians, one of whom suggested it was an Alba. Sure enough, my plant looks like that one, and since I could make a direct comparison to Mme. Plantier, I feel confident they are the same.

All to say that, what I was crowing about is not BdN, but Mme. Plantier or another Alba. (I'm removing my photo of it from this rose commentary and may post it under MP.) I'm also going to keep trying to get a Boule de Neige!
REPLY
Discussion id : 121-095
most recent 23 APR 20 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 23 APR 20 by Magnus95
Can someone comment on the repeat flowering of this Bourbon? Thanks.
REPLY
Discussion id : 114-803
most recent 7 JAN 19 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 7 JAN 19 by Spotto
Can anyone explain why HMF describes this rose as a Noisette? I raise the question because it is nothing like a Noisette and the stated breeding is consistent with its appearance and fragrance i.e it is a white damask type of Bourbon rose.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 3 posted 7 JAN 19 by Margaret Furness
Lacharme was apparently someone who believed "if you're onto a good thing, stick to it". He released at least five roses with the same parentage. They are often called Bourbon-Noisettes, presumably on a historical basis, since Boule de Neige was called a hybrid Noisette in 1880.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 3 posted 7 JAN 19 by Spotto
Thanks for the explanation, Margaret. The rose stubbornly refuses to embrace its attributed classification.
REPLY
Reply #3 of 3 posted 7 JAN 19 by Margaret Furness
Mme Alfred de Rougement: "the French have consistently classed it as hybrid Noisette" - since 1863!
REPLY
© 2022 HelpMeFind.com