HelpMeFind Roses, Clematis and Peonies
Roses, Clematis and Peonies
and everything gardening related.
DescriptionPhotosLineageAwardsReferencesMember RatingsMember CommentsMember JournalsCuttingsGardensBuy From 
'Temple Bells' rose Reviews & Comments
Discussion id : 58-514
most recent 11 MAR 13 SHOW ALL
 
Initial post 11 NOV 11 by Charles Valin
It is a very healthy rose but the stems can be prone to crown gall.
REPLY
Reply #1 of 10 posted 11 NOV 11 by Kim Rupert
That seems to be a problem with its species background. The Fairy (and many of its offspring) and all of the Flower Carpet series are highly susceptible to crown gall here in Southern California. Disease resistant? Very! But, if gall is around, they'll get it.
REPLY
Reply #2 of 10 posted 11 NOV 11 by Charles Valin
Do you think crown gall susceptibility comes with R. wichuraiana? Is there any other species that would give good foliar disease resistance without passing on crown gall susceptibility?
REPLY
Reply #3 of 10 posted 11 NOV 11 by Kim Rupert
Davidii has brought in good vertical resistance to black spot, but once that resistance is breached, it collapses. Everything has its Achilles' Heel. Multiflora has good disease resistance, except to mildew. The best thing to do is grow them in your climate and determine which has the least offensive faults in your opinion, then work with those. Basye's Legacy isn't a species, but a species hybrid and has some sterling traits. Depending upon what it's crossed with, you can bring in rust potential. Others, no disease issues. You might look at some of the newer near species hybrids which are showing very nice resistance, such as Centre Stage.
REPLY
Reply #4 of 10 posted 11 NOV 11 by Kim Rupert
Oh, sorry, I forgot the question, yes, it appears to me that wichurana does have the gall susceptibility.
REPLY
Reply #5 of 10 posted 11 NOV 11 by Charles Valin
Centre Stage is based on R. luciae onoei, isn't that a dwarf form of R. wichuraiana? Crown gall issues might come in via this species as well? Is Centre Stage crown gall free in your experience? What do you make of R. majalis (R. cinnamomea) for disease resistance? I will be trying Basye's Legacy next season, does it repeat flower?
REPLY
Reply #6 of 10 posted 11 NOV 11 by Kim Rupert
So far, Centre Stage is OK here. Majalis I am not that familiar with, not having grown it. Legacy can rebloom in climates which have a very long spring season, or where weather remains spring-like for a long period. I'm inland where there is a definite break between spring and summer. Along the coast here, where it seems like spring until very later (often September), Legacy, like many other once flowering roses, can continue setting new flowers for many, many months.
REPLY
Reply #7 of 10 posted 12 NOV 11 by Charles Valin
I have seed in the fridge of Temple Bells x Blanc Double de Coubert. I am still impatient to see the results despite the crown gall issue!
REPLY
Reply #8 of 10 posted 12 NOV 11 by Kim Rupert
Raise them! Gall may not be an issue in your climate, nor with your genetic combination. THE single most important variable is location, location, location.
REPLY
Reply #9 of 10 posted 11 MAR 13 by Simon Voorwinde
I have a few 'Temple Bells' x 'Therese Bugnet' seedlings here and have tried in the past to get other rugosa (e.g. 'Ann Endt') to marry with 'Temple Bells'. The result has been either nothing or poor, failure-to-thrive, offspring. One TB x 'Therese Bugnet' seedling has started to kick on a bit but unfortunately it doesn't like the hot summers here and is starting to show disease issues. Maybe it will do better in the ground??? I think there are a few significant compatibility issues between rugosa and wichurana and a lot will need to be done to find one that isn't crippled by these issues.

'Temple Bells' crosses very nicely with most moderns, however, to make a lot of miniatures that show excellent health. Crown gall issues may be avoided by using resistant versions of modern repeating floribunda etc. If you can, I would also recommend crossing TB with other species from within the Synstylae section to try and overcome these crown gall issues. TB does a good job of taming such seedlings (a little) and can then be used as you would use TB though the repeating gene(s) might be lost. I have TB x Rosa sinowilsonii seedlings this season that are looking outstanding and I can hardly wait to get these to flowering stage to see what they can achieve. They look exactly like sinowilsonii except everything is in miniature! Really healthy, vigorous and so cute I just wanna squeeze their cheeks every time I see them. I also have TB x a thornless multiflora that is very healthy and once flowering. This season I am going to collect its OP hips to see if I can recover the thornlessness.

I'm just thankfull that I don't seem to have crown gall here... Apparently it IS here but I've never seen it!

The results have been very worthwhile but you need to have the room the grow these out as they probably will be quite large.
REPLY
Reply #10 of 10 posted 11 MAR 13 by Kim Rupert
Good to see you Simon! I'm glad someone is working with this combination. I hope you don't have gall. It isn't a fun thing to deal with and it seems to be worsening over the past few years.
REPLY
Discussion id : 51-002
most recent 23 DEC 10 HIDE POSTS
 
Initial post 23 DEC 10 by Simon Voorwinde
Super fertile both ways. Has accepted every pollen I've put on it and the seeds germinate easily.
REPLY
© 2025 HelpMeFind.com