On many of the English roses, there is a note right on the front page that says, "this is one of the English rose varieties that has been replaced." I wish you would go through and take this off. In whose opinion? Replaced by what? Many of your contributors go on to say the rose named is one of their favorites and the best perfomer in their garden, wouldn't live without it, overlooked maybe but terrific. There is in fact a lot of background controversy to this issue (such as how do you make lots more money if people still buy your old roses). It sounds like one of your readers just pasted that comment all over the place, like some kind of authority on the subject. The most you can say is that SOME varieties do not grow as well in SOME places, but have been found to be terrific in OTHER places. And all the varieties posted as "replaced" are perfectly fine roses.